Quote:
Originally Posted by ToySoldier#34
Moose doesn't belong in this group, or the HOF
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by drop2d
Well, this one his just wrong.
|
Curt Schilling: 79.5 WAR | Mussina: 82.8 WAR
Not that WAR is the end-all, be-all. But they have some pretty similar stats otherwise. Curt played 2 extra years and thus has a bit more on the counting side. Mussina is definitely lowest of the group I included him with that is in the hall, but I think he's the dividing line. I don't think Schilling is better than him, so I don't think he belongs. Even if they're 100% equivalent players (and they're pretty close) I don't think we need 2 of the same player from the same era in the HoF.
If Moose doesn't belong (and I can get behind that, because fuck the Yankees), then neither does Schilling.
Bloody/Ketchup sock can stay in the Hall, though.