Quote:
Originally Posted by clayj41
I can't put Matt Ryan ahead of him simply because of his almost complete lack of meaningful accomplishment, team or otherwise. The others are all correct.
|
Wilson's advantage is his legs obviously. Ryan can make every single throw and is much more accurate.
Team success or lack-thereof does not always reflect an individual's talent, which is often a skewed stance or opinion of lots of fans (not you; speaking generally).
But I do agree they both fall in the #6 to #9 range as far as QB talent goes.
It's easy (and wrong) to point to Julio and Roddy and say Ryan should win SBs.
But his OL has been poor and defense non-existent. With only a handful of pieces around him, the majority of QBs could only go so far. Very overlooked factors.
Example yes Luck is better and also had a better OL than Ryan, but with no run game and defense only so much "success" was/can be reached.