Virginia In the Rain is still one of my favorite things they've ever done. It's absolutely brilliant and I'm grateful to have that song captured forever in such a beautiful way.
I also love the studio version of Again and Again - that one turned out so well.
There are a handful of other songs that I still really dig, too. Black and Bluebird, She (the production on this is terrific), Idea Of You, Here On Out, bkdkdkdd, and Samurai Cop come to mind. Wish B&BB was not cut short and that it didn't immediately transition into the sound of a siren (why?!), as that would have been SUCH a great studio song with a 1-2 minute jam at the end.
Do You Remember, Come Tomorrow, Come On Come On, When I'm Weary and Can't Stop are songs I'm generally fine with and can find at least one or two musical elements that I enjoy, but not songs that I ever specifically seek out to hear on their own.
That Girl is You could have been awesome if Dave really locked in a great vocal, but the studio version is pretty jarring to me. I get that he was going for a one vocal take type of feel, but I think that turned out to be a missed opportunity. Feels a little sloppy and lackluster as a result. Much better song in a live environment, for sure.
Overall: If I had to give this album a grade after a few years with it, I'd say B- / C+.