Album Survivor(s)

[bowa36]

that is a seriously tough choice

[haiku.warrior]

Hold Me Down is godly. Sad it's most likely going this round

[crounsa810]

Spotlight (9 votes, 33.3%) has been eliminated

Songs in:
#36 (1 vote, 3.7%)
#40 (1 vote, 3.7%)
Blue Water (0 votes, 0%)
Deed is Done (7 votes, 25.9%)
Hold Me Down (8 votes, 29.6%)
Water into Wine (1 vote, 3.7%)

[crounsa810]

Well, its time had to come I guess. Hold Me Down (18 votes, 50%) has been eliminated.

Songs in:
#36 (0 votes, 0%)
#40 (0 votes, 0%)
Blue Water (1 vote, 2.8%)
Deed is Done (13 votes, 36.1%)
Water into Wine (4 votes, 11.1%)

[crounsa810]

Today's elimination is Deed is Done (19 votes, 73.1%).

Songs in:
#36 (2 votes, 7.7%)
#40 (1 vote, 3.8%)
Blue Water (3 votes, 11.5%)
Water into Wine (1 vote, 3.8%)

[crounsa810]

Water Into Wine (13 votes, 39.4%) has been eliminated.

Final 3:
#36 (6 votes, 18.2%)
#40 (3 votes, 9.1%)
Blue Water (11 votes, 33.3%)

[crounsa810]

#40 and Blue Water (10 votes, 37% each) have tied, so they are both eliminated.

#36 (7 votes, 25.9%) is the album survivor.

Here's the final rankings of 1990's Live Only Songs:

#36
#40/Blue Water [tied]
Water into Wine
Deed is Done
Hold Me Down
Spotlight
Get In Line/Dreamed I Killed God/Little Thing [tied]
People People
Heathcliff's Haiku Warriors
Doobie Thing
Toy Soldiers
True Reflections/Once on a Wild Afternoon/Me and Her [tied]
Sister '94/Richmond Jam [tied]
A Thing That Happens

Next up: The 2000's Live

A Dream So Real
Butterfly
Crazy Easy
Falling off the Roof
Gas into Fire
Good Good Time
Hurricane
I Won’t Give It Away
Light Lift Me Up
Loving Wings
Prelude to Grace
Shotgun
Sugar Will

[crounsa810]

First cut is I Won't Give it Away (7 votes, 19.4%)

Songs in:
A Dream So Real (4 votes, 11.1%)
Butterfly (5 votes, 13.9%)
Crazy Easy (0 votes, 0%)
Falling off the Roof (4 votes, 11.1%)
Gas into Fire (3 votes, 8.3%)
Good Good Time (1 vote, 2.8%)
Hurricane (3 votes, 8.3%)
Light Lift Me Up (4 votes, 11.1%)
Loving Wings (0 votes, 0%)
Prelude to Grace (4 votes, 11.1%)
Shotgun (1 vote, 2.8%)
Sugar Will (0 votes, 0%)

[crounsa810]

Today's elimination is Gas Into Fire (8 votes, 27.6%)

Songs in:
A Dream So Real (3 votes, 10.3%)
Butterfly (4 votes, 13.8%)
Crazy Easy (0 votes, 0%)
Falling off the Roof (3 votes, 10.3%)
Good Good Time (0 votes, 0%)
Hurricane (2 votes, 6.9%)
Light Lift Me Up (6 votes, 20.7%)
Loving Wings (0 votes, 0%)
Prelude to Grace (2 votes, 6.9%)
Shotgun (0 votes, 0%)
Sugar Will (1 vote, 3.4%)

[crounsa810]

Today's elimination is Light Lift Me Up (10 votes, 45.5%)

Songs in:
A Dream So Real (4 votes, 18.2%)
Butterfly (3 votes. 13.6%)
Crazy Easy (0 votes, 0%)
Falling off the Roof ( 0 votes, 0%)
Good Good Time (0 votes, 0%)
Hurricane (3 votes, 13.6%)
Loving Wings (0 votes, 0%)
Prelude to Grace (1 vote, 4.5%)
Shotgun (0 votes, 0%)
Sugar Will (0 votes, 0%)

[mdel21]

Where is Joyride on this one?

[Fpuonpko]

Originally Posted by mdel21

Where is Joyride on this one?

Joyride was released as a studio b-side track

[crounsa810]

I forgot yesterday. Hurricane was eliminated yesterday, and today's elimination is Falling Off the Roof (10 votes, 50%)

Songs in:
A Dream So Real (3 votes, 15%)
Butterfly (4 votes, 20%)
Crazy Easy (0 votes, 0%)
Good Good Time (0 votes, 0%)
Loving Wings (0 votes, 0%)
Prelude to Grace (3 votes, 15%)
Shotgun (0 votes, 0%)
Sugar Will (0 votes, 0%)

[mdel21]

Originally Posted by Fpuonpko

Joyride was released as a studio b-side track

For what album? How did I miss this fact?

[Cptn. Monkeyman]

Originally Posted by mdel21

For what album? How did I miss this fact?

Stand Up, along with Trouble With You

[crounsa810]

Prelude to Grace (11 votes, 64.7%) has been eliminated.

Songs in:
A Dream So Real (3 votes, 17.6%)
Butterfly (3 votes, 17.6%)
Crazy Easy (0 votes, 0%)
Good Good Time (0 votes, 0%)
Loving Wings (0 votes, 0%)
Shotgun (0 votes, 0%)
Sugar Will (0 votes, 0%)

Voting is about to start getting real, real, REAL tough pretty soon.

[crounsa810]

A Dream So Real (8 votes, 44.4%) has been eliminated.

Do people really like Butterfly this much??

Songs in:

Butterfly (6 votes, 33.3%)
Crazy Easy (0 votes, 0%)
Good Good Time (2 votes, 11.1%)
Loving Wings (1 vote, 5.6%)
Shotgun (0 votes, 0%)
Sugar Will (1 vote, 5.6%)

[jmkratt]

Originally Posted by crounsa810

A Dream So Real (8 votes, 44.4%) has been eliminated.

Do people really like Butterfly this much??

Songs in:

Butterfly (6 votes, 33.3%)
Crazy Easy (0 votes, 0%)
Good Good Time (2 votes, 11.1%)
Loving Wings (1 vote, 5.6%)
Shotgun (0 votes, 0%)
Sugar Will (1 vote, 5.6%)

I like it better than everything that has been eliminated thus far and more than Loving Wings but I think it's on it's way out now.

[crounsa810]

Butterfly (23 votes, 65.7%) has been eliminated.

This is a tough final 5

Songs in:
Crazy Easy (2 votes, 5.7%)
Good Good Time (6 votes, 17.1%)
Loving Wings (3 votes, 8.6%)
Shotgun (0 votes, 0%)
Sugar Will (1 vote, 2.9%)

[crounsa810]

Today we say goodbye to Good Good Time (18 votes, 37.5%).

Songs in:
Crazy Easy (9 votes, 18.8%)
Loving Wings (13 votes, 27.1%)
Shotgun (7 votes, 14.6%)
Sugar Will (1 vote, 2.1%)

[haiku.warrior]

A Dream So Real >>>> everything in the final 4 except Loving Wings

[jmkratt]

Originally Posted by haiku.warrior

A Dream So Real >>>> everything in the final 4 except Loving Wings

Interesting. ADSR and LW are my least 2 favorite of that group

[Vacubsfan]

Originally Posted by jmkratt

Interesting. ADSR and LW are my least 2 favorite of that group

Same here...Sugar Will and Crazy Easy for me are #1 and #2 on this list.

[Skittles72]

Shotty #1, Crazy-easy #2, Sugar Will #3

[crounsa810]

Today we eliminate Loving Wings (12 votes, 46.2%).

One thing is clear from this particular survivor: this band had at least half an album's worth of material they could have used to create an incredible album, and they left it on the shelf. I get why 2005 was such a kick to the balls for so many fans.

Songs in:
Crazy Easy (7 votes, 26.9%)
Shotgun (4 votes, 15.4%)
Sugar Will (3 votes, 11.5%)

[mdel21]

This is tough. Yes they left Crazy Easy, Shotgun, Good Good Time, Joyride, Hello Again (not truncated), Sugar Will, and Loving Wings on the shelf for Stand Up (for it), Hunger for the Great Light, Everybody Wake Up, Dreamgirl, and Smooth Rider. Absolutely insane to me.

[jmkratt]

Originally Posted by mdel21

This is tough. Yes they left Crazy Easy, Shotgun, Good Good Time, Joyride, Hello Again (not truncated), Sugar Will, and Loving Wings on the shelf for Stand Up (for it), Hunger for the Great Light, Everybody Wake Up, Dreamgirl, and Smooth Rider. Absolutely insane to me.

[crounsa810]

Crazy Easy (26 votes, 49.1%) has been eliminated.

Songs in:
Shotgun (16 votes, 30.2%)
Sugar Will (11 votes, 20.8%)

[jmkratt]

That's incredibly difficult.

[crounsa810]

Originally Posted by jmkratt

That's incredibly difficult.

Currently have 50 votes cast. The results are 50/50