two good discs. the 2017 disc looks fantastic. with all the love the hershey 2006 songs got, i wish they would just release the entire show. it deserves it, and its obvious people like the songs from it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by stlbluespower
so, wait. Warehouse had a poll and these two discs basically delivered the goods? Not sure how that can be construed as anything other than a great job by the Warehouse. Did they also select the exact versions of the requested songs?
|
i wouldn't say giving a list of ~21 songs with dates to members to vote on and then taking 80% of the songs from that list is really a call for kudos to the WH. while they did make some good selections on dates for some songs, the vote was pretty pointless if they took the vast majority of the list anyway. if the 2017 disc was what was voted and that was it, then ya, good job WH. but then they just took the leftovers and threw them onto another disc and called it 2018. thats lazy. should have made a new list, even if the ones that didnt make the 2017 disc were on the new list, with songs replacing the ones already voted for and do another vote. maybe add in some other popular write ins to the list and then see what gets voted for the 2018 disc.
Quote:
Originally Posted by chadizzy1
It was chosen over You Never Know (8/24/03), which came in at #9 in the results and Angel came in at #16.
So I think it's fair to say vote count wasn't relevant. Perhaps they already knew what they wanted to select but wanted us to feel like we had a say in it.
|
when they took 80% of their own list and made 2 discs out of it, i'd say they pretty much knew what they wanted on there. look at the songs that didn't make the cut from the list. a second warehouse and a second grey street. really, only one song was cut, and that was YNK, because they weren't going to put two of anything on the two discs. they needed something to fill in the rest of the space, so they did the write ins.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Vision23
Other than stone, bartender, and FTT are there any actual standout songs that make these unique performances or are we getting pretty standard versions?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
|
i know the WH has the louie louie interpolation. all the 2006 performances are solid. i was at both scranton and hershey that year, so im pretty familiar with those shows. they're solid picks.