SONG BATTLE: You & Me or She

[SeanMH]

SSIA,

which is better?

VOTE!

[cjobes]

Sheeeeeeeeee

[ExistenceNow]

She is bottom 5 in the catalog.

You & Me is cheesy and overplayed but ultimately harmless.

[LaLaLaLaHey]

You and Me - I actually enjoy hearing at shows, contrary to most others here.

[Todefy]

She, by a wide margin

[CDN-DMBfan]

Based my decision off the album versions. Went with you and me. She just doesn’t do anything for me.

[josh4127]

I understand if you don't love or even like She. But you and me is the cheesiest, nothing to it song I have ever heard from this band.

[davem#36]

You and me is pop BS. The music in she is 100000x better as well. Don't know how anyone couldn't like that jam at the end.

[davem#36]

Originally Posted by josh4127

I understand if you don't love or even like She. But you and me is the cheesiest, nothing to it song I have ever heard from this band.

Allll of this.

[LetYouDown22]

She fo sho. Gotta love that STP vibe you get from the song. Takes me back to the 90s alternative era.

[dontdrink36]

She pretty easily.

[comeandsee41]

Originally Posted by ExistenceNow

She is bottom 5 in the catalog.

You & Me is cheesy and overplayed but ultimately harmless.

i'd argue bottom 3

[RSSR]

Definitely She.

[Cscottrun]

Surprised by the She hate. Not an amazing song, but I certainly don't think its bottom 5. I can easily think of 5 worse songs. I really like the live outro.

[josh4127]

Originally Posted by Cscottrun

Surprised by the She hate. Not an amazing song, but I certainly don't think its bottom 5. I can easily think of 5 worse songs. I really like the live outro.

this guy gets it

[ExistenceNow]

Originally Posted by comeandsee41

i'd argue bottom 3

I wouldn't fight you on that.

[coolhotwaves]

I don’t like You and Me but it’s a far better song

[grdfreak]

Originally Posted by LetYouDown22

She fo sho. Gotta love that STP vibe you get from the song. Takes me back to the 90s alternative era.

this!!! I actually love She. The solo with buddy at the end is awesome. I just wish the jam was longer like I also wish on tgiy. There also is some things the band can do with the jam on She that they currently arent doing. I think back to 2010 i believe when they would do cornbread into standup or even this past year with liog into american baby intro. Or something like recently/ants where they all take turns killing it. Just my thoughts now whether they do any of this or anything other than what they are doing now is another thing.

[josh4127]

I am stunned at people choosing You and Me but hey that's why we our entitled to our opinions.

[grilldanmo]

Holy apples and yo-yos comparison...from the perspective of music and lyrics. Always enjoy both and can't pick...

[MiniFlynny34]

She is badass. Don't mind hearing it live but I've already seen it 5 times.

You and Me usually gets a grown for me, yet it literally tore down the fucking house at MSG. Was kinda cool to see.

[chadizzy1]

She and it’s not even close

[SmoothD41]

She by 10,000 calories.

[Dannyyankou]

She is entering -1 territory for me. Still a 0, but not much longer.

[BruceW]

She is not even close to bottom 5. It’s also much better than You & Me.

[TheStone91]

Originally Posted by BruceW

She is not even close to bottom 5. It’s also much better than You & Me.

Yep, this. But She is not good or even average.

[Strider_BTCS]

I like She and don't mind seeing it at a show. You and Me, on the other hand, I'd be happy if I never heard it again.

[YankeesDMB41]

If Dave could sing She without sounding like shit, it would be a lot better live. You and Me still sucks though

[Cross the ice]

You & Me, no question. And as for Y&M being cheesy, it may not contain lyrics like: “She hypnotize me with her groove,
She collect the stars she super moon... if you wait too long to taste, the juju is gone” but I can suffer through it.

[coldengrey12]

I know the post-bridge section in You & Me before it loops back around to the chorus is the best music in either song.