Big Whiskey vs. Come Tomorrow

[eggsrsweet]

Which album do you like more?

[RSSR]

Come Tomorrow. But I have Come Tomorrow much more easily over AFTW. Come Tomorrow over Big Whiskey And The GrooGrux King is a much closer decision for me.

[grilldanmo]

Right now it’s CT, but. We’ve been listening to it a ton. Likely would be BW if I weee to listen to it tonight.

[Dannyyankou]

Big Whiskey is a great, underrated album

[ExistenceNow]

Big Whiskey.

Come Tomorrow is the worst.

[TimHonks]

CT for me, but it's close.

[ToySoldier#34]

CT, I am a CT fan and don't like Big Whiskey aside from Baby Blue

[jasonfilatov]

Ranking below. Big Whiskey and it's not close.

Lying in the Hands of God
Squirm
She
Virginia in the Rain
Baby Blue
Dive In
Here on Out
Again and Again
Funny the Way It Is
Shake Me Like a Monkey
Why I Am
Alligator Pie
Black and Bluebird
Seven
That Girl is You
Samurai Cop (Oh Joy Begin)
Idea of You
Do You Remember
Can't Stop
Spaceman
Time Bomb
Come On Come On
You & Me
When I'm Weary
Come Tomorrow

[dobyblue]

There are currently only four tracks off BW I'll listen to - LITHOG, Dive In, Baby Blue and FTWII
Come Tomorrow I am still enjoying at least 8 songs from.

So CT

[chadizzy1]

Rating them by the +/- scale:
Big Whiskey +4
Come Tomorrow +7

Come Tomorrow just has way more songs on it that I want to listen to.

Big Whiskey
Grux 1
Shake Me Like a Monkey 0
Funny The Way It Is 1
Lying in the Hands of God 1
Why I Am 2
Dive In 3
Spaceman 3
Squirm 3
Alligator Pie 4
Seven 3
Time Bomb 4
Baby Blue 5
You & Me 4

Come Tomorrow
Samurai Cop 1
Can’t Stop 2
Here On Out 2
That Girl Is You 2
She 3
Idea of You 4
Virginia In The Rain 3
Again and Again 4
Bkdkdkdkdkdkd 4 (too short to rate)
Black & Blue Bird 4
Come On Come On 5
Do You Remember 6
Come Tomorrow 7
When I’m Weary 7

[Strider_BTCS]

Big Whiskey
Grux 1
Shake Me Like a Monkey 0
Funny The Way It Is 0
Lying in the Hands of God 1
Why I Am 1
Dive In 1
Spaceman 2
Squirm 3
Alligator Pie 4
Seven 3
Time Bomb 4
Baby Blue 4
You & Me 3

Come Tomorrow
Samurai Cop 0
Can’t Stop 0
Here On Out 0
That Girl Is You 1
She 2
Idea of You 3
Virginia In The Rain 4
Again and Again 5
Bkdkdkdkdkdkd 5 (too short to rate)
Black & Blue Bird 5
Come On Come On 5
Do You Remember 5
Come Tomorrow 4
When I’m Weary 5

Big Whiskey at +3 and Come Tomorrow is a +5. They are both decent albums with songs I really enjoy but both below the Big 3, Busted Stuff, and AFTW.

[eggsrsweet]

Yeah, there's more songs on CT that I like. Baby Blue is literally the only song I like on BW.

[stlbluespower]

BW by quite a bit for me.

[stlbluespower]

Originally Posted by eggsrsweet

Yeah, there's more songs on CT that I like. Baby Blue is literally the only song I like on BW.

Squirm, LITHOG???????

[dontdrink36]

Originally Posted by Dannyyankou

Big Whiskey is a great, underrated album

This. Overplay has soured many people's opinion of it which is unfortunate.

[SmoothD41]

Tough call for me. I like both of them, probably a slight edge to CT though.

[mthawk07]

Originally Posted by ExistenceNow

Big Whiskey.

Come Tomorrow is the worst.

I'll just +1 this post.

[dobyblue]

Originally Posted by stlbluespower

Squirm, LITHOG???????

The one on the right is a top 5 song for me since LWS, the one on the left has an okay verse but overall I do as the song's title suggests when I hear it. I can gladly skip from Dive In right to Baby Blue if I'm on the CD.

[LetYouDown22]

Both very good albums that I prefer studio vs. live. I give CT the edge at this time just because it's fresher to me, and feels closer to a Some Devil-ish type of work.

[ToySoldier#34]

Rating them by the +/- scale
Big Whiskey -2
Come Tomorrow +8


Big Whiskey
Grux 1
Shake Me Like a Monkey 0
Funny The Way It Is 0
Lying in the Hands of God 1
Why I Am 0
Dive In 0
Spaceman 0
Squirm 1
Alligator Pie 0
Seven -1
Time Bomb -2
Baby Blue -1
You & Me -2

Come Tomorrow
Samurai Cop 1
Can’t Stop 2
Here On Out 3
That Girl Is You 2
She 3
Idea of You 4
Virginia In The Rain 5
Again and Again 6
Bkdkdkdkdkdkd 7
Black & Blue Bird 7
Come On Come On 8
Do You Remember 8
Come Tomorrow 7
When I’m Weary 8

[#41Tom]

Originally Posted by ExistenceNow

Big Whiskey.

Come Tomorrow is the worst.

[snake911]

BW by a country mile. I enjoy/find highly listenable every song on BW except for Seven (ignore the live-setting-beat-to-deathness of the songs, thats a good studio album). CT has 4 songs I really enjoy, 2-3 that are ok, and the rest I would be find not hearing again.

[eggsrsweet]

Originally Posted by stlbluespower

Squirm, LITHOG???????

Both trash. Especially Squirm.

[bubba40]

Not even close- Big Whiskey

[ShotgunDMB]

Come Tomorrow. More natural sounding.

[Szat]

Both pretty even for me and very different alblums. Need to give CT more time to soak in. VITR and again and again are really strong cuts tho. AFTW trumps both tho.

[AndySlash]

they both only have 2-3 songs i'd care to listen to on a regular basis. i'd give a slight edge to the new record, but neither of them do much for me. give me away from the world instead.

[BTBaboon]

Big Whiskey for me.

Big Whiskey
Grux 1
Shake Me Like a Monkey 1
Funny The Way It Is 2
Lying in the Hands of God 3
Why I Am 3
Dive In 4
Spaceman 5
Squirm 6
Alligator Pie 7
Seven 6
Time Bomb 6
Baby Blue 7
You & Me 7

Come Tomorrow
Samurai Cop 0
Can’t Stop -1
Here On Out 0
That Girl Is You -1
She -1
Idea of You 0
Virginia In The Rain 1
Again and Again 2
Black & Blue Bird 3
Come On Come On 2
Do You Remember 3
Come Tomorrow 3
When I’m Weary 3

[Cptn. Monkeyman]

Big Whiskey

Grux 1
Shake Me Like a Monkey 0
Funny the Way It Is 1
Lying in the Hands Of God 2
Why I Am 2
Dive In 3
Spaceman 4
Squirm 5
Alligator Pie 6
Seven 6
Time Bomb 7
Baby Blue 8
You & Me 7

Come Tomorrow

Samurai Cop 1
Can’t Stop 0
Here On Out 1
That Girl is You 2
She 3
Idea Of You 4
Virginia In the Rain 5
Again & Again 6
Black & Blue Bird 7
Come On Come On 7
Do You Remember 8
Come Tomorrow 8
When I’m Weary 7


Love both, voted Big Whiskey

[ExistenceNow]

Shake Me is a -1 live, but it's a better studio track than 75% of CT.