Quote:
Originally Posted by ToySoldier#34
I'm not the one who said unlistenable in the first place, I just don't find anything wrong with someone saying it.
I wish Tim wasn't in the band and I'm not a big electric guitar solo fan in general although there are exceptions, he occasionally does exciting things, Trey playing on LIOG at SPAC in '04 was great.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KllCYO55I48 ... listenable? Sure. No falsetto, no belting or power, always the same emotional level for an entire show with a lot of the same phrasing, same feel the whole time. KevinTH puts more emotion into a show. For me as a listener jamming is secondary to the structure of a song and everything else I just listed, I'm sure there is good electric guitar playing in Phish.
|
It was 2007.
I never said you did say any of those things. I was never addressing you. Just that one comment from someone not named you.
You chose a quiet Trey solo acoustic show to prove your point? A little strange but ok, yes, it is quiet and his voice does not have much range.
You do realize there are quite a few Phish songs that have more unique, dynamic, and intricate structures that do not include improvisational jamming than anything DMB would ever attempt right? I’m not sure what your point there was.
Yes, TS, there is “good electric guitar” in Phish...