Album Survivor(s)

[crounsa810]

Another tie. Rye Whiskey & Exodus are finished.

All Along the Watchtower (1 vote, 2.3%)
Angel From Montgomery (4 votes, 9.1%)
Burning Down the House (4 votes, 9.1%)
Down by the River (2 votes, 4.5%)
Funny How Time Slips Away (4 votes, 9.1%)
Long Black Veil (2 votes, 4.5%)
The Maker (1 vote, 2.3%)
Sledgehammer (2 votes, 4.5%)
Time of the Season (4 votes, 9.1%)

[crounsa810]

Funny How Time Slips Away has been eliminated.

All Along the Watchtower (2 votes, 2.1%)
Angel From Montgomery (17 votes, 17.7%)
Burning Down the House (15 votes, 15.6%)
Down by the River (9 votes, 9.4%)
Long Black Veil (1 vote, 1%)
The Maker (6 votes, 6.3%)
Sledgehammer (8 votes, 8.3%)
Time of the Season (16 votes, 16.7%)

[mdel21]

Can you put how many votes the song gets eliminated with?

I must be in the minority, but I can't stay sledgehammer and BDTH

[Fpuonpko]

I think maybe AATW should not have been included. While obviously it is a cover, the band has essentially made it their own (and there are people who might even assume it is their own original). I think AATW will win, or at least get very close

[crounsa810]

Time of the Season (11 votes, 26.2%) has been eliminated.


Songs in:
All Along the Watchtower (0 votes, 0%)
Angel From Montgomery (6 votes, 14.3%)
Burning Down the House (9 votes, 21.4%)
Down by the River (9 votes, 21.4%)
Long Black Veil (2 votes, 4.8%)
The Maker (1 vote, 2.4%)
Sledgehammer (4 votes, 9.5%)

I'm still confused how Cortez didn't outlast some of these.

[crounsa810]

Down by the River (17 votes, 38.6%) has been eliminated. I'm very surprised that Sledgehammer and BDTH have hung on for so long.

Songs in:
All Along the Watchtower (1 vote, 2.3%)
Angel From Montgomery (4 votes, 9.1%)
Burning Down the House (13 votes, 29.5%)
Long Black Veil (1 vote, 2.3%)
The Maker (3 votes, 6.8%)
Sledgehammer (5 votes, 11.4%)

[Fpuonpko]

as expected, AATW continues on lol

[crounsa810]

Burning Down the House (26 votes, 40.6%) has been eliminated

Songs in:
All Along the Watchtower (0 votes, 0%)
Angel From Montgomery (21 votes, 32.8%)
Long Black Veil (4 votes, 6.3%)
The Maker (5 votes, 7.8%)
Sledgehammer (8 votes, 12.5%)

[crounsa810]

ANOTHER tie.

Sledgehammer and Angel from Montgomery (17 votes, 40.5% each) are eliminated.

Final 3 Songs in:

All Along the Watchtower (2 votes, 4.8%)
Long Black Veil (2 votes, 4.8%)
The Maker (4 votes, 9.5%)

[crounsa810]

The Maker (34 votes, 41%) has been eliminated.

Final two:

All Along the Watchtower (18 votes, 21.7%)
Long Black Veil (31 votes, 37.3%)

[Fpuonpko]

well pointless since AATW won as expected lol

[crounsa810]

Final results:

All Along the Watchtower
Long Black Veil
The Maker
Sledgehammer/Angel from Montgomery [tied]
Burning Down the House
Down by the River
Time of the Season
Funny How Time Slips Away
Rye Whiskey/Exodus [tied]
If I Had a Boat/A Whiter Shade of Pale [tied]
Cortez the Killer/For the Beauty of Wynona [tied]
Thank You
Blackbird/Waste [tied]
Fly Like an Eagle/Wild Horses [tied]
Hey Hey My My/Solsbury Hill [tied]
Redemption Song
Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard/Melissa [tied]
Back in Black/Stayin' Alive/ Friend of the Devil/ Tangerine [tied]
Runnin' Down a Dream/In My Life [tied]
The Needle and the Damage Done/ Take Me to the River [tied]
Money/ Sweet Caroline/ Still Water [tied]
Black Water/ Eyes of the World/ Right Place Wrong Time/ Sugar Man [tied]
Don't Fear the Reaper/ A Pirate Looks at Forty/ Kashmir/ Slip Slidin' Away [tied]
Worried Man Blues/ Tell Me Something Good/ Take Me to Tomorrow/ Superstition/ Super Freak/ Long Train Running/ Like a Hurricane/ Is Chicago Is Not Chicago/ Imagine/ Good Times Bad Times/ Get Up (I Feel Like Being a) Sex Machine/ Buena/ Brass Monkey/ American Tune [tied]

[crounsa810]

Next up is Live-Only songs, spanning 2010-2020.

Be Yourself
Bismarck
Blackjack
Break For It
Clown
Death on the High Seas
Kill the Preacher
The Ocean and the Butterfly
Plastic Girl
Singing from the Windows
Song for Billijo

Looking at that list, yeesh. Apart from maybe Bismarck and the 2020 songs, it's been a rough decade for live-only songs.

[Zachman285]

Originally Posted by crounsa810

Next up is Live-Only songs, spanning 2010-2020.

Be Yourself
Bismarck
Blackjack
Break For It
Clown
Death on the High Seas
Kill the Preacher
The Ocean and the Butterfly
Plastic Girl
Singing from the Windows
Song for Billijo

Looking at that list, yeesh. Apart from maybe Bismarck and the 2020 songs, it's been a rough decade for live-only songs.

I mostly agree, though I think Break for It is a solid song. Not great - but on par with the better stuff they've written post Busted Stuff.

[jmkratt]

I don't know. I like the Ocean and the Butterfly too thus far.

[crounsa810]

First one to bite the dust is Plastic Girl (10 votes, 32.3%)

Songs in:
Be Yourself (7 votes, 22.6%)
Bismarck (0 votes, 0%)
Blackjack (5 votes, 16.1%)
Break For It (0 votes, 0%)
Clown (5 votes, 16.1%)
Death on the High Seas (1 vote, 3.2%)
Kill the Preacher (0 votes, 0%)
The Ocean and the Butterfly (0 votes, 0%)
Singing from the Windows (0 votes, 0%)
Song for Billijo (3 votes, 9.7%)

[crounsa810]

Be Yourself (14 votes, 48.3%) is eliminated.

Songs in:

Bismarck (0 votes, 0%)
Blackjack (3 votes, 10.3%)
Break For It (1 vote, 3.4%)
Clown (4 votes, 13.8%)
Death on the High Seas (1 vote, 3.4%)
Kill the Preacher (1 vote, 3.4%)
The Ocean and the Butterfly (1 vote, 3.4%)
Singing from the Windows (1 vote, 3.4%)
Song for Billijo (3 votes, 10.3%)

[crounsa810]

Blackjack has been eliminated

[crounsa810]

Clown & Song for Billijo have been eliminated with 7 votes each.

Bismarck (0 votes, 0%)
Break For It (0 votes, 0%)
Death on the High Seas (3 votes, 15%)
Kill the Preacher (1 vote, 5%)
The Ocean and the Butterfly (0 votes, 0%)
Singing from the Windows (2 votes, 10%)

[crounsa810]

Death on the High Seas (12 votes, 48%) has been eliminated.

Final 5:

Bismarck (2 votes, 8%)
Break For It (2 votes, 8%)
Kill the Preacher (4 votes, 16%)
The Ocean and the Butterfly (3 votes, 12%)
Singing from the Windows (2 votes, 8%)

[crounsa810]

Kill the Preacher (11 votes, 35.5%) has been eliminated.

Final 4:
Bismarck (2 votes, 6.5%)
Break For It (3 votes, 9.7%)
The Ocean and the Butterfly (8 votes, 25.8%)
Singing from the Windows (7 votes, 22.6%)

[crounsa810]

The Ocean and the Butterfly (17 votes, 68%) has been eliminated.

Songs in:
Bismarck (1 vote, 4%)
Break For It (3 votes, 12%)
Singing from the Windows (4 votes, 16%)

[crounsa810]

Singing from the Windows (15 votes, 62.5%) has been eliminated.

Final 2:
Bismarck (0 votes, 0%)
Break For It (9 votes, 37.5%)

[crounsa810]

Bismarck has won, defeating Break for It

Final results/rankings were:

Bismarck
Break For It
Singing from the Windows
The Ocean and the Butterfly
Kill the Preacher
Death on the High Seas
Clown/Song for Billijo [tied]
Blackjack
Be Yourself
Plastic Girl

[crounsa810]

We're on to the 1990's. There were 33 votes this time, and our eliminations from Round 1 are:
A Thing That Happens (25 votes, 75.8%)
Richmond Jam (16 votes, 48.5%)
Sister '94 (16 votes, 48.5%)
Me and Her (15 votes, 45.5%)
Once on a Wild Afternoon (15 votes, 45.5%)
True Reflections (15 votes, 45.5%)

Songs in:
#36 (1 vote, 3%)
#40 (1 vote, 3%)
Blue Water (1 vote, 3%)
Deed is Done (4 votes, 12.1%)
Doobie Thing (10 votes, 30.3%)
Dreamed I Killed God (3 votes, 9.1%)
Get in Line (7 votes, 21.2%)
Heathcliff’s Haiku Warriors (2 votes, 6.1%)
Hold Me Down (5 votes, 15.2%)
Little Thing (6 votes, 18.2%)
People People (7 votes, 21.2%)
Spotlight (6 votes, 18.2%)
Toy Soldiers (6 votes, 18.2%)
Water into Wine (3 votes, 9.1%)

[crounsa810]

Toy Soldiers (yesterday) and Doobie Thing (5 votes, 20%) have been eliminated.

Songs in:
#36 (1 vote, 4%)
#40 (1 vote, 4%)
Blue Water (0 votes, 0%)
Deed is Done (0 votes, 0%)
Dreamed I Killed God (3 votes, 12%)
Get in Line (1 vote, 4%)
Heathcliff’s Haiku Warriors (4 votes, 16%)
Hold Me Down (2 votes, 8%)
Little Thing (1 vote, 4%)
People People (4 votes, 16%)
Spotlight (3 votes, 12%)
Water into Wine (0 votes, 0%)

[jmkratt]

Damn, Toy Soldiers is the shit.

[crounsa810]

Another great one bites the dust. Heathcliff's Haiku Warriors (13 votes, 26%) has been eliminated.
Songs in:

#36 (0 votes, 0%)
#40 (1 vote, 2%)
Blue Water (0 votes, 0%)
Deed is Done (2 votes, 4%)
Dreamed I Killed God (5 votes, 10%)
Get in Line (5 votes, 10%)
Hold Me Down (6 votes, 12%)
Little Thing (2 votes, 4%)
People People (10 votes, 20%)
Spotlight (4 votes, 8%)
Water into Wine (2 votes, 4%)

[crounsa810]

People People (9 votes, 25.7%) has been eliminated.

How the hell are Get In Line, Spotlight, and Deed is Done still in this thing???

Songs in:
1. #36 (1 vote, 2.9%)
2. #40 (0 votes, 0%)
3. Blue Water (0 votes, 0%)
4. Deed is Done (2 votes, 5.7%)
5. Dreamed I Killed God (7 votes, 20%)
6. Get in Line (6 votes, 17.1%)
7. Hold Me Down (4 votes, 11.4%)
8. Little Thing (2 votes, 5.7%)
9. Spotlight (3 votes, 8.6%)
10. Water into Wine (1 vote, 2.9%)

[crounsa810]

Get In Line, Little Thing, and Dreamed I Killed God (4 votes, 23.5% each) have been eliminated.

Songs in:
#36 (0 votes, 0%)
#40 (1 vote, 5.9%)
Blue Water (0 votes, 0%)
Deed is Done (0 votes, 0%)
Hold Me Down (3 votes, 17.6%)
Spotlight (1 vote, 5.9%)
Water into Wine (0 votes, 0%)