Quote:
Originally Posted by TwoStep2888
This is accurate.
"Shaky cam" was used well and worked aesthetically and thematically for Greengrass' excellent Bourne Supremacy and Ultimatum, but Forster didn't know how and when to use it properly and Quantum of Solace was a directorial mess. Also, yeah, huge waste of villain potential. Glad we have Mendes now, loved Skyfall, excited for this one.
|
I'll give you an example of when it shouldn't be used, in Bourne Supremacy when Bourne is talking to Marie's brother informing him of her death the camera is wobbling all around the place. One character is sitting on the bed, the other is standing talking, no-one comes crashing through the roof, nothing explodes, the POV is not first person, it's not being shot on a boat, what is the point of the shaky cam in this scene?
The second and third Bourne films IMHO were great IN SPITE OF Greengrass, not because of him. Now I agree that he's much better overall at it than Forster who thought he was shooting a Prodigy video and not a Bond film, but it doesn't excuse Greengrass for me. I would much rather have seen what Doug Liman would have done with those two installments. They have very little rewatch value for me thanks to Greengrass.
Seeing what Liman did with the amazing Sci-Fi ride Edge of Tomorrow this year leads me to believe even more that those two movies would have been better had they kept him on, just as QoS would have been better with Martin Campbell.