Quote:
Originally Posted by F-A89
I think the orchestra is unnecessary. Boyd providing Dave with a single violin accompaniment would have made it much more emotional. I know it's a "sad" song, I don't need an orchestra to nail that home.
EDIT: And if Boyd did the accompaniment, it would have been his chance to shine on the album
|
Well, the orchestra is definetely doing things and creating emotions that Boyd could not do on that song. I feel like we're just reading into needing to find a place for Boyd on the album. I think we should just take the song as is and judge it on its own merits, not whether we think it's "right" for boyd to be playing on it.