Re: **Frank Zappa Thread**
I've been a huge Zappa fan for over 10 years. I've heard (or at least am familiar with) all of his official albums (which now numbers nearly 100). He is indisputably a genius composer, songwriter, guitarist, bandleader, producer/engineer, and all-around artist.
I know people hate Greatest Hits albums, but I think _Strictly_Commercial_ is actually a very good introduction to Zappa. Also, if you can find a torrent of the 1996 NPR radio show "Frank Zappa: American Composer," that's also a great primer.
I've recently been studying Frank really hard again. Despite his genius, here are the problems I see, personally (only my opinion, mind you):
1. He made music, sometimes, that only HE enjoyed. Try sitting through an entire album of his Synclavier compositions. I don't know anyone who can stomach more than one or two pieces.
2. He almost always could ruin a great melody by adding too many notes and going in off-kilter directions with it.
3. The musicianship of his bands was amazing, but again, I like a little more restraint and melody.
4. He would complain about not being able to get on American radio, like he was some kind of victim, when he made a bunch of offensive (or otherwise non-accessible) songs that would not have fit on any radio format. He wanted to have his artistic/rule-breaking cake and eat the exposure one too.
5. He was so convinced of his superiority that he had very little perspective on his own material.
6. He was a real misanthropist, and very mean-spirited.
7. I know he satirized EVERYone, but sometimes I think it went a little too far. For instance, I think a lot of his satire of blacks, women, and gays was downright bigoted. He could get around the blame (like by having a black man sing his racial commentary songs), but the material is still there, clear as day.
Now don't get me wrong, Zappa is one of the kings of American music, but a lot of people are turned off by his art. I get it. He's not for everyone, and even the people he *IS* for need to understand that he's problematic, and probably no one will like all the music. A lot of it just isn't fun to listen to.
|