Its very simple...

[Malaguy]

Originally Posted by PTstoy

am I the only one who will be very VERY sad if A Dream SO Real is on the album...I really dislike the tune...a lot...

no, you're not the only one. this song blows my hairy asshole. i'd also prefer not to see loving wings on an album taking up valuable space, that could be filled with something not utterly boring.

and did the OP forget "Idea Of You"?

[warehouseguy]

Originally Posted by mikemartone

Put out an album that looks like this:

A Dream So Real
Cornbread
JTR
Sweet Up And Down
Blue Water
#27
Monkey Man
Crazy Easy
Sugar Will
Eh Hee
Shotgun
Loving Wings

Fans will love this album because its sick and it will buy them more time to work on totally new stuff.

That way they can put out another album shortly after and act like a band that isnt in retirement.

The Eagles come out with albums more frequently.

I love these posts where folks put almost every unreleased song they know on a track list... the band will never release Blue Water, doesnt sound like it will return to Sugar Will/Crazy-Easy, and Monkey Man is DEAD... and didn't some of it get adopted into So Right?

Ill match you on Shotgun, Eh Hee, Sweet Up & Down, Cornbread, BUT what about Idea of You?

[Zs727]

Originally Posted by tedies

Are we allowed to have at least 1 song we've never heard? Personally I'd be upset if at least 1/2 to 3/4 of the album is not new

For sure. One of the best parts of a new album is hearing songs for the first time (good or bad)

[Beebz]

Originally Posted by mikemartone

Put out an album that looks like this:

A Dream So Real
Cornbread
JTR
Sweet Up And Down
Blue Water
#27
Monkey Man
Crazy Easy
Sugar Will
Eh Hee
Shotgun
Loving Wings

Nah.

I'd rather have:

New Song
New Song
New Song
New Song
New Song
#27
New Song
New Song
New Song
New Song
New Song
New Song
Shotgun
New Song
New Song

And yeah, A Dream So Real blows. So does Sugar Will

[zdaddy]

Heres what will be on it:

#27
Cornbread
Shotgun
A Dream So Real
Loving Wings

6-9 new songs (maybe an improved Falling Off The Roof, Some Devil Intro, MyspaceTV #4 Song)

Heres what shouldnt and wont be on it:

JTR, SUAD, and Monkey Man - we already have "studio versions" of these songs and they are spectacular. Id rather they play them live more anyways.

Eh Hee, The Idea Of You - Eh Hee has already been released in some capacity, and is much better D&T. TIOY has greatly declined from early 06.

Sugar Will, Crazy Easy, GGT, Joy Ride - we already have a studio joy ride (horrible yes), and the rest are not only dead, but grossly overrated on these boards.

Blue Water - come on, get real!

[spoot388]

Originally Posted by zdaddy

Heres what will be on it:

#27
Cornbread
Shotgun
A Dream So Real
Loving Wings

6-9 new songs (maybe an improved Falling Off The Roof, Some Devil Intro, MyspaceTV #4 Song)

Heres what shouldnt and wont be on it:

JTR, SUAD, and Monkey Man - we already have "studio versions" of these songs and they are spectacular. Id rather they play them live more anyways.

Eh Hee, The Idea Of You - Eh Hee has already been released in some capacity, and is much better D&T. TIOY has greatly declined from early 06.

Sugar Will, Crazy Easy, GGT, Joy Ride - we already have a studio joy ride (horrible yes), and the rest are not only dead, but grossly overrated on these boards.

Blue Water - come on, get real!

wow, i thought i was the only one who thought the 04 songs were vastly overrated and nowhere near being album worthy.


i agree with what you said about everything except Eh Hee, IOY, ADSR, and LW. i think IOY will be on there because its the one true single type song they have, especially if SUAD won't be on it. the other 3 i think are toss ups. could be and could not be, but won't surprise me either way.

[zdaddy]

Originally Posted by spoot388

wow, i thought i was the only one who thought the 04 songs were vastly overrated and nowhere near being album worthy.


i agree with what you said about everything except Eh Hee, IOY, ADSR, and LW. i think IOY will be on there because its the one true single type song they have, especially if SUAD won't be on it. the other 3 i think are toss ups. could be and could not be, but won't surprise me either way.

I like the riffs of Sugar Will and GGT, but those songs are a serious bore. Very anticlimactic. Crazy Easy is just plain boring, musically, lyrically, and energeticly. Hello Again and Joy Ride were the best from that year, and they got slaughtered.