Rodgers v. Cutler

[jaking1185]

Originally Posted by DMBZeppelin

What? There was no arguing point. Just that it obviously didn't pan out that way. Not sure what you're getting at exactly.

Well I was obviously not being serious. Hard to win a SB when you're a blob.

Back when I posted that Rodgers was getting sacked a lot. Part of it was the O line, and the rest was Rodgers holding on to the ball too long. Unlike the Bears the Packers addressed both things and they are not a problem anymore.

The funny thing is, Bears fans around here say "OMG Cutler gets sacked all the time. He's getting all jumpy and gun-shy" but over the last 3 seasons Cutler was sacked 98 times. Rodgers however was sacked 115 times. Rodgers hasn't let that affect him. I feel that the sacks have become a convenient excuse for Cutler's underperforming. I think it has a lot more to do with the team's lack of adddressing the receiving talent.

[TwoStep2888]

wow, poll closed on a perfect tie. neat

[jaking1185]

Seemed like the right place for this...

https://www.msn.com/en-us/sports/nfl...a9I&ocid=edgsp

[JRS1386]

What a great thread to demonstrate bias

[TwoStep2888]

haha hmm

[DMBZeppelin]

I'd like to change my answer to Mitch Trubisky.

Talk about going in two different directions. Cutler was on the rise coming off a Pro Bowl for one of the NFL's best offenses in Denver, and Rodgers took over a team that went to the NFC Championship game and wound up 6-10. Since then no one has been better then Rodgers (not even Tom).

Honestly I question Packers management for only getting 1 ring with this guy (so far) because he should be the GOAT when it's all said and done.

[smokew11]

Originally Posted by DMBZeppelin

I'd like to change my answer to Mitch Trubisky.

Talk about going in two different directions. Cutler was on the rise coming off a Pro Bowl for one of the NFL's best offenses in Denver, and Rodgers took over a team that went to the NFC Championship game and wound up 6-10. Since then no one has been better then Rodgers (not even Tom).

Honestly I question Packers management for only getting 1 ring with this guy (so far) because he should be the GOAT when it's all said and done.

hard to say Rodgers has been better than Brady, with the 2 SB wins and 3 appearances

[FromTheMorning]

Originally Posted by TwoStep2888

wow, poll closed on a perfect tie. neat

Guess we can't know who's better then.

[rickyh24]

Holy shit. The first page of this thread is amazing.

[rickyh24]

Originally Posted by BotheU2Fan

How do you figure Rodgers is more talented? Cutler is faster, smarter, stronger armed. I wouldn't kick either out of bed, but Jay Cutler is the most physically talented QB in the league.

[rickyh24]

Originally Posted by DMBZeppelin

Cutler.



I am without a doubt bias, but I'm not a homer. I would have told you this in 2007 and 2008.

[Timebomb07]

Originally Posted by AlexK79

Cutler is bigger, more mobile, and has a stronger arm. (Not that Rodgers is deficient in any of those categories.) If you're just talking raw, measurable physical talent, Cutler comes out on top.

It's a tough call overall. Cutler is better physically speaking, Rodgers might be a little better decision maker at this point. Cutler has a better O-line and RB, Rodgers has much better wideouts. I'd honestly call this a wash.

One thing for certain is that both of these guys are gonna be very good for the next 8-10 years and it's going to be fun to watch them duel, especially since they are good friends off the field.

This post is great.

"One thing for certain is that both (edit: one) of these guys are gonna be very good for the next 8-10 years and it's going to be fun to watch them duel (edit: Rodgers kick the shit out of Cutler every time they play)."

[Lee3691]

Originally Posted by rickyh24

Holy shit. The first page of this thread is amazing.

I think the Bears fans who posted have won the award for most delusional fans ever

[ToySoldier#34]

Originally Posted by DMBZeppelin

Talk about going in two different directions. Cutler was on the rise coming off a Pro Bowl for one of the NFL's best offenses in Denver, and Rodgers took over a team that went to the NFC Championship game and wound up 6-10. Since then no one has been better then Rodgers (not even Tom).

Honestly I question Packers management for only getting 1 ring with this guy (so far) because he should be the GOAT when it's all said and done.

[rickyh24]

Bears fans were serious when they said cutler was the most talented qb in the league

[jaking1185]

That's bo for you...

[TwoStep2888]

Originally Posted by FromTheMorning

Guess we can't know who's better then.

it will remain a mystery for all of time

[cry_minarets458]

I'm a fan of post #12 in this thread

[Tiduwho]

Originally Posted by Tiduwho

I disagree. I think Rodgers right now is the better decision maker and not as apt to make mistakes, but on that same coin, he holds the ball too long because he doesn't want to make a bad throw. This ends up in him ending in one sack after another, basically Big Ben jr. Yes, the Packers O-Line is awful, but Rodgers was at fault for a number of those sacks the other night because he doesn't make the snap throw and stands there waiting for things to develop.

"Potential" I think they are even. Cutler, in my opinion, has more talent though. The guy's arm is off the charts. His pocket awareness is fantastic. While Rodgers buys a little time in there, Cutler avoids the rush time and again and can deliver a ball just as he's about to be hit because of his release time.

Cryptic how correct he was about the potentials of the two quarterbacks.

[crashintonickdm]

Cutler got his payday based on potential. Never ever lived up to it.

[jayman414]

When I saw this thread get bumped, I just clicked on the last page without seeing who started the thread. I thought to myself as I was scrolling to the last page, what dope thought this would even be close and be thread worthy...then I realized I was the dope that created the thread.

Rodgers has been and will be--unless the Packers do another HOF QB after him--my favorite Packer and player to watch. I have thoroughly enjoyed watching Cutler struggle for many years in Chicago and Rodgers all the while has been setting the gold standard for QB play.